Think about the idea that your sister has never been interested in good boys.... this is important! She herself has a "toxic" character, and she apparently needs people like that too...What is there to save her from? Maybe she's found her soul mate.
I pictured your sister so clearly...I had a girlfriend like that. She was always yelling if she was reprimanded. It was impossible to stop her from doing anything. So I decided I wasn't going to boss her around. She became much calmer. No one tells her how to live her life. You should try it. I'm sure your sister will change.
Hi! Tell me, why can't you say anything back to your sister? She yells and you don't say anything? Why don't you all get together as a family and chase her bad boyfriend away?
@samir45591 we have done alot, she will make hurt herself or us if we will gonna fight with her.
@eldamayer139 thankyou seriously for this suggestion. we will surely try from today onwards
@brent54560 yes that's right even we thought that too. but we knew her so much as she will not stay with him too, as he will not be manage her expensive life, which she is not getting it now.
@katherine Even if she doesn't stay with him, it will be her life lesson and choice. You will be there for her and help her through the negative emotions. Maybe she'll start to appreciate you more.
Hi. This is a tough situation but see how much ever you stop her she will still continue to do what she wants to .
this is what you can do :
Communication is the important key for any relationship. i want you to first think about how important is your sister for you and the good times you have shared with her. Then Sit with her and just have normal chat with her about your childhood memories. Tell her about her strength and good things she has done so far.Then start the topic about her boyfriend and calmly listen to her side of story of why she likes the boy and what goodness does she see in him.
If you have valid points try explaining to her why you feel he is not good but in calm way not placing allegations on her that she has made a wrong choice always. Negative comments will only bring bitterness in your relationship with her. It would make her rebel and turn her against you.
Caring for your family doesn't mean you have to solve all the problems for her. If she still wants to continue just leave it. Tell her that you will always stand by her as a family and will be always there around as a backbone.
if you further need any help just reach me at veena.pragmatic@gmail.com
Hello!
Yes, the situation is indeed difficult, but I think there is a way out.
I would advise you and your parents to change your behavior. Essentially, everything that is happening between your family members and your younger sister can be called a confrontation. Arguments, scandals, and persuasion have not led to anything, and may have even worsened the situation. Therefore, I suggest that you switch to a negotiation strategy.
Most likely, your sister now perceives you and your parents as people who want to interfere with her happiness, but it is important for you to convey to her that this is not the case. For this, your entire family will have to communicate differently, more constructively. Let's provide a general scheme that can be used during the conversation.
1) Make a plan
During a conversation it is difficult to control emotions and not to resort to personal attacks. To prevent this from happening, we recommend that you prepare a plan in advance and try to stick to it.
2) Determine your intention
Be honest with yourself: understand what exactly you want to achieve in the process of communicating with your sister. Throughout the conversation, keep this goal in mind - it will allow you to stay on course and avoid an argument.
3) Choose the right time and place for the conversation
Choose a time that suits everyone for the conversation. Eliminate or minimize distracting factors. If possible, turn off the TV, do not answer calls, put aside the newspaper, and avoid multitasking while communicating with each other. For example, having an important conversation while driving a car is definitely not worth it.
4) Talk about yourself
Express feelings and thoughts, not criticism, judgments, convictions, and do not give advice. Yes, you are trying to convey your point of view to your sister, but she perceives it only as an attempt to suppress her. Therefore, at this stage, just talk about your feelings regarding the situation.
5) Don't interrupt
Let your sister finish before you start responding. After expressing herself, she will be more open and interested in hearing you out.
6) Don't get stuck on your own opinion
Do not succumb to the temptation to dispute what you do not agree with. Instead of correcting your sister, share your point of view on the situation.
Also, try to find at least two points in her speech that you could agree with. This does not mean that you need to change your point of view, the task is to better understand your sister and become more open to her position. You can even conduct a small experiment: when communicating with your sister or any other person whose opinion you disagree with, just mentally ask yourself the question: "What if this is true?"
7) Put yourself in her shoes
Trying to "pull" another person to your position usually ends in conflict. This is quite natural: no one wants to admit that they are wrong and give up their opinion. Instead, try to understand what really drives your sister, why she behaves in a certain way.
8) Ask questions
You are unlikely to convince your sister of something. Instead, it is better to push her towards certain reflections. For example, you can ask a question: "Are you sure you want to be with this person?" or "Tell me, how do you see your future life with...?". It is important to do this gently, without hinting at a certain personal position.
9) Accept your sister's position
Accepting your sister's point of view does not mean giving up your own beliefs. It means giving her the right to have her own opinion, no matter how strange it may seem to you.
10) Speak with the right attitude.
When we discuss sensitive topics with our loved ones, we often feel anger and irritation. Naturally, with such a mood, constructive dialogue is impossible. Therefore, before starting a dialogue, tune in to a positive mood. Here, I will also recommend you one "secret" technique: during the dialogue with your sister, periodically mentally say to her the phrase: "I love you and wish you well." You will see how such a mood will change the quality of your communication and improve your relationship for the better.